This is why I think this is the answer I use the original source material in this discussion, because it was a reference that the movie cast and crew used : The Watchmen comic uses talk bubbles to show the changes that occur to the way Rorschach presents himself outwardly. However whithout the Rorschach "face" Kovacs is shown talking in a different tone. Improve this answer. Ben Plont Ben Plont 4, 19 19 silver badges 40 40 bronze badges.
Hmm, interresting answer. He doesn't seem to have many problems with grammar in the movie, but he indeed isn't a man of many words and uses rather short sentences. So it was part of Rorschach 's character. Yet what I don't completely understand if it is even answered in the novel is, if this was a concious decision of Kovacs and thus he was playing Rorschach that way or if it was really innate to the person of Rorschach forming in Kovacs and thus an actual transformation his voice underwent together with his personality.
Or maybe first the former and later the latter. So was it then really Rorschach speaking or rather Kovacs playing Rorschach. But from your descriptions of how this event changed him it's probably the former, I guess. There's a switch with the dogs episode, where that voice becomes Rorschach's real voice.
Prior to that, Rorschach spoke with Kovacs' voice. I think the personalities take turns. When the mask is on, it's Rorschach speaking. When it's off it's Kovacs or Rorschach impersonating Kovacs.
While not being a comic or graphic novel enthusiast in any way, I more and more feel the desire to get my hands on this one. Having seen the movie quite some times already since its release, the last time really got me hooked somehow.
Show 2 more comments. Featured on Meta. Now live: A fully responsive profile. Version labels for answers. Linked Related Hot Network Questions. Their findings suggest that, yes, the Rorschach test does have substance to it, especially when the test is conducted on those who are suffering from a mental illness.
While not all of the variables that the Rorschach test identifies are strongly supported, a great deal of them are. The most supported variables include those that help to detect psychotic disorders, mental distress, and the risk of suicide in an individual. On the other side of the test, those who are seeking to discredit the Rorschach inkblot test argue that it is unreliable and unable to accurately detect any mental health issues , aside from some psychotic disorders.
The biggest issue seen by those on the opposing side is that there is no specific system of measurement that works for every person tested. Everyone's interpretation of the test is unique, and because of this, there is room for error in the results of the test.
This can be especially harmful if the test is being administered in a court of law or in another situation where accuracy is vital. The second major issue that is seen in the Rorschach inkblot test is that it can't always be reliable by those who are not interested in the test or its results. For example, let's imagine that a young teenager has a psychotic disorder and is being forced to see a psychiatrist. The psychiatrist decides to administer the test to the teenager. The teenager, already knowing exactly what the test is due to seeing it somewhere in the media, decides to give the most basic answers.
The test then concludes that the teenager is fine rather than identifying the underlying disorder. Both sides present valuable arguments, and the test is still currently being used by psychiatrists today.
While the validity of the Rorschach inkblot test is debatable, the mental illnesses that it is seeking to identify are not. If you believe that you have a mental illness, the best course of action to take is to seek help immediately. Don't know where to start? BetterHelp is the world's largest e-counseling platform that provides accessible, affordable, and convenient online counseling.
Clicking the link above will take you to a short questionnaire that will help you connect with the right online counselor for you!
Search Topics. Related Articles What Is Flooding? Psychology, Definition, And Applications. At the end of the Watchmen, Adrian Viedt has killed millions of people faking an attack on the world. In the graphic novel he fakes an alien invasion. In the movie he fakes an attack by Dr. Regardless the result is the same, Veidt has successfully scared the world away from nuclear war.
All of the surviving protagonists, though horrified, are thankful that the war has been averted. Manhattan decides that life is valuable and goes to another galaxy to create some. The only character who objects is Rorschach. To him people must know what happened even if it brings back the threat of war. To maintain silence, he is murdered by Dr Manhattan, because after all whats one more body among millions?
In real life the Cold War never got as close to an atomic apocalypse as in the book. When the Soviets invaded Afghanistan the US never fueled up the bombers, or if it had, cooler heads prevailed.
0コメント